How the writing is marked

The Gentle Marker helps teachers show a writer what worked in a draft and what to try next.

What a classroom score tells you

For narrative and persuasive writing, our rubrics adapt the ten criteria in ACARA’s NAPLAN writing marking guides. A narrative can earn 47 marks and a persuasive piece can earn 48. Informative writing uses a separate classroom rubric.

Each criterion has its own score. For example, a story can have well-chosen vocabulary while its punctuation makes dialogue hard to follow. The report points to the student’s own words so a teacher can check the judgement and choose a revision to teach.

The Gentle Marker is an independent resource from CamLoc Education Group Pty Ltd. ACARA does not endorse this service. About the NAPLAN writing test.

Reading the NAPLAN proficiency levels

Since 2023, official NAPLAN reports have used four proficiency levels for each tested year. ACARA describes what students typically demonstrate in a timed task with a set prompt. A classroom draft, which may have been planned, scaffolded or revised, cannot be converted into a national level.

Year 5 writing examples, summarised from ACARA’s descriptions
Official levelWhat the writing might show
Needs additional supportThe writer puts a familiar idea on the page. Parts of a story or argument are recognisable, and some sentences have a clear ending.
DevelopingSeveral ideas relate to the topic. The reader can follow some connections between sentences, and much of the vocabulary is everyday language.
StrongDetails support the main ideas. The structure suits the task, some words are chosen precisely, and most sentence boundaries are clear.
ExceedingThe writer organises details into paragraphs that engage the reader. Varied sentences, precise words and punctuation help carry the meaning.

Use these examples to discuss one feature at a time. For example, ask a student to point to the detail that makes a character’s decision believable. A single feature does not establish a national proficiency level.

ACARA provides separate writing descriptions for Years 3, 5, 7 and 9. Its earlier bands and raw-score tables applied to past tests on a different reporting scale. Read the official proficiency descriptions · About the earlier bands.

The narrative and persuasive classroom descriptors adapt the supplied Writing Narrative marking guide and Writing Persuasive marking guide, © Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) 2027. Descriptors have been rephrased. CC BY 4.0.