Skip to report
The Gentle Marker

Classroom sample · Student report

Earth or Excessive

Rubric total30 / 48Persuasive · 10 criteria

These marks describe this piece of writing. Only the national test gives a NAPLAN proficiency level. NAPLAN writing levels explained.

What you did well

In your spending paragraph, you name things money could pay for on Earth, including food and education. That gives readers a real choice to think about instead of just asking them to agree that saving money is good.

You ask readers to picture children in the future without enough food or a home. The short question straight after that scene works because readers now have a particular outcome to decide whether they would accept.

Your next step

Revisit the end of your spending paragraph. You return to the point about saving money, but a reader might still wonder who would benefit if that money stayed on Earth and what difference it would make to them.

Try this revision

Choose one use for the money from your list. Replace the last sentence of that paragraph with two sentences: show what the money could do for someone, then explain why that example makes spending it on Earth a better choice. Ask a partner to tell you who gains and why. If they can answer both from your paragraph, your edit has worked.

Words you spelt well

Excessive, pressure, achieve, guard, economy, decision, education, business, safeguard, Imagine, generation, choice

Your rubric scores

CriterionScoreWhat it means and an example from your writing
Audience5/6How you help your reader follow and care about what you are saying.
Have you read that less than 0.001% of humans can afford to live in space?
Text structure3/4How you organise the beginning, middle and ending of your piece.
If we put more time in going to Earth we will guard the economy, save wildlife and do what's right.
Ideas3/5How you develop your main ideas with details.
we will save money for better purposes like education, food, and business
Persuasive devices3/4How you use language and reasons to persuade your reader.
Have you read that less than 0.001% of humans can afford to live in space? That’s only a few thousand!
Vocabulary3/5How precisely your word choices express what you mean.
guard the economy
Cohesion2/4How you link ideas so the reader can follow them.
guard the economy, save wildlife and do what's right.
Paragraphing2/3How you group sentences and choose where to start a new paragraph.
Protecting Earth is a smart decision to us save thousands later on.
Sentence structure3/6How you build and vary your sentences.
Have you read that less than 0.001% of humans can afford to live in space?
Punctuation3/5How your punctuation helps the reader hear and understand each sentence.
Have you read that less than 0.001% of humans can afford to live in space? That’s only a few thousand!
Spelling3/6How accurately you spell the words you use.
to much pressure

Original writing

Year 5 persuasive writing

Earth or Excessive

Have you read that less than 0.001% of humans can afford to live in space? That’s only a few thousand! Us humans must face we put to much pressure on moving to nowhere. We must act adapt, and achieve. If we put more time in going to Earth we will guard the economy, save wildlife and do what's right. Lets start gliding towards greatness, and stop this idea from being light year away.

Protecting Earth is a smart decision to us save thousands later on. If we act now we act now we will save money for better purposes like education, food, and business ,then waiting the money. We need to start to put more thought into the economy. Clearly, we need to save the money for better purposes.

Protecting Earth will safeguard life in the long run. Every time the tern a blind eye, plants fade. Every time the tern a blind eye, animals suffer. Imagine the next generation standing in open fields hungry, homeless, and angry, because we moved but failed. Will you let this happen? Every time the tern a blind eye, the human raise goes down.

Protecting Earth is the just choice. Scientists have discovered that, over 50% of your oxygen comes from the sea, no other planet can support life like this! Is it fair that the next humans will be floating to nowhere? We must act, Will you?

Australians must act to play our part in saving our homeland. Doing so with conserve money, preserve life , and do what we must do. Its time to play our part in saving our Earth. Lets start growing from our mistakes ,and take the ticket to save our home.

The Gentle Marker · Writing feedback for Sample L