Classroom sample · Teacher report
Earth or Excessive
These marks describe this piece of writing. Only the national test gives a NAPLAN proficiency level. NAPLAN writing levels explained.
Original writing
Year 5 persuasive writing
Earth or Excessive
Have you read that less than 0.001% of humans can afford to live in space? That’s only a few thousand! Us humans must face we put to much pressure on moving to nowhere. We must act adapt, and achieve. If we put more time in going to Earth we will guard the economy, save wildlife and do what's right. Lets start gliding towards greatness, and stop this idea from being light year away.
Protecting Earth is a smart decision to us save thousands later on. If we act now we act now we will save money for better purposes like education, food, and business ,then waiting the money. We need to start to put more thought into the economy. Clearly, we need to save the money for better purposes.
Protecting Earth will safeguard life in the long run. Every time the tern a blind eye, plants fade. Every time the tern a blind eye, animals suffer. Imagine the next generation standing in open fields hungry, homeless, and angry, because we moved but failed. Will you let this happen? Every time the tern a blind eye, the human raise goes down.
Protecting Earth is the just choice. Scientists have discovered that, over 50% of your oxygen comes from the sea, no other planet can support life like this! Is it fair that the next humans will be floating to nowhere? We must act, Will you?
Australians must act to play our part in saving our homeland. Doing so with conserve money, preserve life , and do what we must do. Its time to play our part in saving our Earth. Lets start growing from our mistakes ,and take the ticket to save our home.
Rubric evidence and judgement
All ten persuasive criteria are shown. Marks are provisional for teacher review. The original classroom prompt and any shared model wording were not available.
Observed form. Persuasive essay with a direct appeal to readers.
The statistics are assessed as claims used to persuade, not as verified facts. No wording has been excluded on an assumption that it came from missing classroom material.
The intended subject in the three repeated warnings about turning a blind eye is unclear. No additional simple-word errors have been recorded for those subject words; resolving them would not change the spelling score.
A confirmed simple-word misspelling limits Spelling to at most 3 out of 6.
Audience
5 / 6
Have you read that less than 0.001% of humans can afford to live in space?
Imagine the next generation standing in open fields hungry, homeless, and angry, because we moved but failed. Will you let this happen?
Australians must act to play our part in saving our homeland.
The writer asks readers to consider who could afford to leave Earth, then makes the choice personal by asking them to imagine its consequences for children. The closing appeal gives Australian readers a shared responsibility. These choices are deliberately persuasive, although the unsupported opening figure and some unclear claims limit the voice’s credibility.
The question immediately after the imagined scene asks the reader to take a position rather than merely picture an outcome.
Text structure
3 / 4
If we put more time in going to Earth we will guard the economy, save wildlife and do what's right.
we will save money for better purposes like education, food, and business
Protecting Earth will safeguard life in the long run.
Protecting Earth is the just choice.
Australians must act to play our part in saving our homeland.
The introduction previews economic, environmental and moral reasons to protect Earth. The body takes them up in that order, and the conclusion turns the case into a call for collective action. All three components function, but the body does not consistently back its reasons with detailed evidence.
The closing paragraph does a distinct job: it identifies who should act after the body has explained why.
Ideas
3 / 5
we will save money for better purposes like education, food, and business
Imagine the next generation standing in open fields hungry, homeless, and angry, because we moved but failed.
Protecting Earth is the just choice. Scientists have discovered that, over 50% of your oxygen comes from the sea, no other planet can support life like this!
The writer gives examples of what money could fund on Earth, imagines hardship for a future generation, and offers the sea’s contribution to oxygen as a reason to value Earth. These details go beyond a list of reasons. How relocation would cause the hardship, and how the oxygen claim establishes a matter of justice, remain largely unexplained.
The spending examples are the clearest elaboration: they show what the writer believes would be lost by directing money elsewhere.
Persuasive devices
3 / 4
Have you read that less than 0.001% of humans can afford to live in space? That’s only a few thousand!
Imagine the next generation standing in open fields hungry, homeless, and angry, because we moved but failed. Will you let this happen?
Is it fair that the next humans will be floating to nowhere?
Lets start growing from our mistakes ,and take the ticket to save our home.
A statistic framed as a question gives the opening urgency. The strongest appeal pairs an imagined future with a direct challenge to the reader’s conscience. The fairness question continues that appeal, but repeated assertions about saving money and the vague closing metaphor do not maintain the same force.
The questions address the reader directly. Their effect is strongest where a preceding detail gives the reader something specific to judge.
Vocabulary
3 / 5
guard the economy
safeguard life in the long run
next generation
just choice
oxygen comes from the sea
Lets start gliding towards greatness, and stop this idea from being light year away.
The writer distinguishes economic protection, the survival of living things, responsibility to descendants and moral fairness through several precise choices. These are interspersed with general restatements and expressions whose meaning is difficult to pin down, so precision is not consistent across the essay.
The language of protection and fairness conveys the position more precisely than the imagery of motion and distance.
Cohesion
2 / 4
guard the economy, save wildlife and do what's right.
If we act now we act now we will save money for better purposes like education, food, and business ,then waiting the money.
Every time the tern a blind eye, plants fade. Every time the tern a blind eye, animals suffer.
Is it fair that the next humans will be floating to nowhere?
The opening forecast and repeated paragraph openings make the overall argument easy to trace. Locally, however, the reader must reconstruct the comparison about spending, identify an unnamed actor in the repeated environmental warning, and infer the link between oxygen and fairness. These interruptions prevent a consistently smooth first reading.
Repeated wording links the two warnings about living things, but it repeats the unclear reference as well.
Paragraphing
2 / 3
Protecting Earth is a smart decision to us save thousands later on.
Protecting Earth will safeguard life in the long run. Every time the tern a blind eye, plants fade. Every time the tern a blind eye, animals suffer.
Protecting Earth is the just choice.
Australians must act to play our part in saving our homeland.
Three distinct body paragraphs focus on spending, the protection of life and the moral choice. Topic sentences lead into relevant detail, particularly where the second body paragraph moves from life generally to plants, animals and people. The order follows the introduction, but the final body paragraph does not clearly build its fairness claim from the preceding ecological argument.
The break before the final paragraph marks the change from giving reasons to addressing the people being asked to act.
Sentence structure
3 / 6
Have you read that less than 0.001% of humans can afford to live in space?
Protecting Earth is a smart decision to us save thousands later on.
If we act now we act now we will save money for better purposes like education, food, and business ,then waiting the money.
Protecting Earth will safeguard life in the long run.
Imagine the next generation standing in open fields hungry, homeless, and angry, because we moved but failed. Will you let this happen?
Is it fair that the next humans will be floating to nowhere?
Several short statements and questions are correctly formed. Longer sentences also work, including a question containing a reported claim and an imperative developed through a participial phrase and a causal clause. Missing or substituted words and a repeated clause disrupt several other constructions, so control is uneven.
The contrast between the extended imperative and the short question that follows it shows control of sentence length for emphasis.
Punctuation
3 / 5
Have you read that less than 0.001% of humans can afford to live in space? That’s only a few thousand!
Imagine the next generation standing in open fields hungry, homeless, and angry, because we moved but failed. Will you let this happen?
Scientists have discovered that, over 50% of your oxygen comes from the sea, no other planet can support life like this!
We must act, Will you?
Lets start growing from our mistakes ,and take the ticket to save our home.
Most sentences have correct opening capitals and end marks. Question marks, an exclamation mark, contraction punctuation and list commas help the reader hear the argument. Comma splices, missing apostrophes and misplaced commas prevent consistent control.
The comma between the call to act and the final question cannot mark the boundary between those two sentence units.
Spelling
3 / 6
to much pressure
We must act adapt, and achieve.
guard the economy
we will save money for better purposes like education, food, and business ,then waiting the money.
Doing so with conserve money, preserve life , and do what we must do.
then
with
Most simple words and more than twenty distinct common words are correct. Sixteen distinct difficult spellings are credited, but that range cannot override an error on an intended simple word. In particular, the closing prediction requires the simple modal verb will. The earlier degree modifier requires too, which the appendix classes as common, not simple.
The economic sentence contrasts better uses of money with wasting it, supporting a comparative rather than a time connective. Missing contraction apostrophes are assessed under Punctuation.
Spelling evidence
Confirmed simple-word spelling. then → than
Confirmed simple-word spelling. with → will
Difficult (16)
- Excessive · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: the consonant sequence at the start, doubled s and unstressed -ive ending present several spelling decisions.
- pressure · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: doubled s represents the sh sound before an unstressed -ure ending.
- achieve · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 101, persuasive p. 106. Direct appendix match: difficult.
- guard · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 103, persuasive p. 108. Direct appendix match: difficult.
- economy · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 102, persuasive p. 107. Direct appendix match: difficult.
- decision · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 102, persuasive p. 107. Direct appendix match: difficult.
- education · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: the multisyllabic spelling combines a weak medial vowel with the -ation ending.
- business · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 101, persuasive p. 106. Direct appendix match: difficult.
- safeguard · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: the compound retains the less predictable gu spelling of its appendix-listed difficult second element.
- Imagine · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 103, persuasive p. 108. Direct appendix match: difficult; capitalised at the start of a sentence.
- generation · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 103, persuasive p. 108. Direct appendix match: difficult.
- choice · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 101, persuasive p. 106. Direct appendix match: difficult.
- Scientists · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: the plural preserves the unusual initial sci- sequence and the consonant cluster at the end of the occupational noun.
- oxygen · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: medial y represents a short vowel, followed by soft g and an unstressed final syllable.
- support · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 105, persuasive p. 110. Direct appendix match: difficult.
- Australians · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: the demonym preserves the initial Au spelling and the medial vowel sequence before the plural ending.
Year 5 interpretation
For Year 5 in NSW Stage 3, the spending paragraph shows how a writer can build a paragraph around an idea that matters to the reader. It gives examples of what money could pay for on Earth. The next step is to develop one example far enough to show why it supports that choice. This is a teaching judgement about this script, not an official NAPLAN band, a comparison with other students or a reading age.
Ideas · Next descriptor. Elaborated ideas make the particular position more effective.
Audience · Next descriptor. A credible voice and sustained, precise choices manage the relationship with the reader, anticipate their expectations and influence their response.
What you did well
In your spending paragraph, you name things money could pay for on Earth, including food and education. That gives readers a real choice to think about instead of just asking them to agree that saving money is good.
You ask readers to picture children in the future without enough food or a home. The short question straight after that scene works because readers now have a particular outcome to decide whether they would accept.
Your next step
Revisit the end of your spending paragraph. You return to the point about saving money, but a reader might still wonder who would benefit if that money stayed on Earth and what difference it would make to them.
Try this revision
Choose one use for the money from your list. Replace the last sentence of that paragraph with two sentences: show what the money could do for someone, then explain why that example makes spending it on Earth a better choice. Ask a partner to tell you who gains and why. If they can answer both from your paragraph, your edit has worked.
Classroom rubric adapted from the ACARA Writing Persuasive marking guide, © ACARA 2027. Descriptors have been rephrased. Source information · CC BY 4.0.
The figures in this piece are the writer’s claims. Before revising, ask which source supports each one.