Skip to report
The Gentle Marker

Classroom sample · Teacher report

Enceladus or Exile!

Rubric total41 / 48Persuasive · 10 criteria

These marks describe this piece of writing. Only the national test gives a NAPLAN proficiency level. NAPLAN writing levels explained.

Original writing

Year 5 persuasive writing

Enceladus or Exile!

Did you know that Earth gains 200,000 people every day? Our population has boomed from 2.5 billion in the 1950s to over 8 billion today. It is time to explore further, faster and fuller. We must colonise Enceladus - Saturn's second largest moon, in order to keep the budget, save lives and do what's right. So, stop being blasé and blast off into brilliance!

Colonising Enceladus is a cost effective deal for humanity. If we spend money on a new home now we can sidestep a far larger cost down the line. Enceladus can save us trillions because its atmosphere blocks harmful radiation so we don't have to set up any fragile and expensive equipment. Plus, it is even more protected to meteorites than Earth. Why spend countless amounts of money fixing Earth, when we have a new home waiting for us?

Migrating to Enceladus will protect precious life. Picture this, sacred flora being washed away in the raging flood waters. Picture this, a small defenceless joey fleeing her rapidly collapsing home. Picture this a petrified boy sprinting away from his ash covered house as smoke covered the sky behind him. Every time we allow this to happen lives are lost. By moving to Enceladus we will make our future safer for our descendants.

Planning a trip to Enceladus is the ethical choice we should make. 80% of scientists acknowledge that Earth can no longer support life and we must move. Is it fair to leave future generations with one fragile, torn apart planet when we have the knowledge and resources to make a new home. It is vital we fly to Enceladus, it is the choice an advance civilisation should make. By migrating to Enceladus now, we can save the human race from extinction. So will you do what's right?

Humanity must colonise Enceladus. Doing this will save money, keep lives safe and make the responsible choice for humanity. It is time to play your part! So don't miss your chance for a better life or the races of Earth will quickly deplete.

Rubric evidence and judgement

All ten persuasive criteria are shown. Marks are provisional for teacher review. The original classroom prompt and any shared model wording were not available.

Observed form. Argumentative essay with a call to action

Audience

5 / 6

Did you know that Earth gains 200,000 people every day? Picture this, a small defenceless joey fleeing her rapidly collapsing home. 80% of scientists acknowledge that Earth can no longer support life and we must move. So will you do what's right?

The writer gives readers several reasons to support colonisation. The opening invites them to consider population growth, the threatened joey makes the stakes personal, and the closing question asks them to make a moral choice. The unsupported claim of scientific agreement weakens the voice for a sceptical reader.

The reader is addressed first as someone who might not know about the problem and finally as someone responsible for a decision.

Text structure

4 / 4

We must colonise Enceladus - Saturn's second largest moon, in order to keep the budget, save lives and do what's right. Enceladus can save us trillions because its atmosphere blocks harmful radiation so we don't have to set up any fragile and expensive equipment. Migrating to Enceladus will protect precious life. Planning a trip to Enceladus is the ethical choice we should make. Humanity must colonise Enceladus. Doing this will save money, keep lives safe and make the responsible choice for humanity. It is time to play your part!

The introduction states the position and previews three reasons. The body develops them in the promised order: the cost of equipment, the lives at risk and the obligation to future generations. The conclusion brings the reasons back together and turns them into a call to act.

The ending does a distinct job: it shifts from what humanity should do to what the individual reader should do.

Ideas

4 / 5

Enceladus can save us trillions because its atmosphere blocks harmful radiation so we don't have to set up any fragile and expensive equipment. Picture this a petrified boy sprinting away from his ash covered house as smoke covered the sky behind him. Is it fair to leave future generations with one fragile, torn apart planet when we have the knowledge and resources to make a new home.

The writer explains a proposed saving by identifying equipment that would supposedly be unnecessary. The disaster scenes give the safety argument concrete stakes, and the fairness question extends it to people not yet born. These details strengthen the position, but the writer assumes that settlement is feasible and safer rather than establishing that crucial comparison.

The scenes illustrate the danger of staying on Earth more fully than the argument explains how moving would protect the lives depicted.

Persuasive devices

4 / 4

So, stop being blasé and blast off into brilliance! Why spend countless amounts of money fixing Earth, when we have a new home waiting for us? Picture this, sacred flora being washed away in the raging flood waters. Picture this, a small defenceless joey fleeing her rapidly collapsing home. Picture this a petrified boy sprinting away from his ash covered house as smoke covered the sky behind him. It is time to play your part!

The devices sustain their effect by changing with the reason being argued. Alliteration makes the opening challenge memorable; a rhetorical question frames repair as the costly choice; repeated imperatives ask the reader to visualise loss. The final direct appeal converts concern into a demand for action.

The sequence from threatened vegetation to an animal and then a child gives the repetition a growing emotional effect.

Vocabulary

4 / 5

sidestep a far larger cost down the line because its atmosphere blocks harmful radiation a small defenceless joey fleeing her rapidly collapsing home By migrating to Enceladus now, we can save the human race from extinction. the races of Earth will quickly deplete.

Precise choices recur across the argument. The writer distinguishes an immediate expense from a larger future cost, names a radiation hazard, and chooses actions that make the joey's danger visible. The final warning is less exact about who would be lost and what would happen to them, limiting the case for level 5.

The vocabulary is most effective when it identifies a specific threat or shows a living thing responding to it.

Cohesion

4 / 4

keep the budget, save lives and do what's right. Every time we allow this to happen lives are lost. By moving to Enceladus we will make our future safer for our descendants. Is it fair to leave future generations with one fragile, torn apart planet when we have the knowledge and resources to make a new home. Humanity must colonise Enceladus. Doing this will save money, keep lives safe and make the responsible choice for humanity.

The three opening commitments guide the reader through the whole essay and return in the conclusion. Within the body, the reference after the disaster scenes gathers the examples into a single consequence. Concern for descendants then carries the safety argument into the discussion of fairness.

The links work between sections as well as between adjacent sentences; the reader does not have to reconstruct the order of reasons.

Paragraphing

3 / 3

Colonising Enceladus is a cost effective deal for humanity. If we spend money on a new home now we can sidestep a far larger cost down the line. Migrating to Enceladus will protect precious life. Picture this, sacred flora being washed away in the raging flood waters. By moving to Enceladus we will make our future safer for our descendants. Planning a trip to Enceladus is the ethical choice we should make. So will you do what's right? Humanity must colonise Enceladus.

Each body paragraph has a distinct purpose. The first develops a cost comparison; the second slows the pace with three scenes of loss; the third builds on those losses to ask what present readers owe future generations. The separate conclusion brings the reader back to the decision.

The order raises the stakes from financial consequences to loss of life and then to moral responsibility.

Sentence structure

4 / 6

If we spend money on a new home now we can sidestep a far larger cost down the line. Enceladus can save us trillions because its atmosphere blocks harmful radiation so we don't have to set up any fragile and expensive equipment. Plus, it is even more protected to meteorites than Earth. It is vital we fly to Enceladus, it is the choice an advance civilisation should make. So will you do what's right?

Most constructions work, including a fronted condition, a causal explanation with a further consequence, and short questions that change the pace. Control is less consistent in the preposition used for protection and the adjective form used to describe a civilisation. Meaning remains clear, but the errors are not confined to one ambitious sentence.

The two clauses in the statement of necessity are identifiable despite the incorrect punctuation between them.

Punctuation

3 / 5

Picture this, sacred flora being washed away in the raging flood waters. Picture this a petrified boy sprinting away from his ash covered house as smoke covered the sky behind him. Is it fair to leave future generations with one fragile, torn apart planet when we have the knowledge and resources to make a new home. It is vital we fly to Enceladus, it is the choice an advance civilisation should make. By migrating to Enceladus now, we can save the human race from extinction. So will you do what's right?

Well over four fifths of intended sentences have clear opening and closing boundaries. Apostrophes, proper-noun capitals, question marks and some phrasing commas are correctly used. A full stop closes a direct question, a comma joins independent clauses, and the repeated invitations to picture a scene lack a consistently clear mark introducing the image.

The correctly marked final question in the ethics paragraph contrasts with the earlier question closed by a full stop.

Spelling

6 / 6

blasé and blast off into brilliance! fragile and expensive equipment 80% of scientists acknowledge that Earth can no longer support life an advance civilisation responsible choice

Every attempted simple word is correctly spelt in context. The appendix matches alone establish 13 distinct correct difficult words and two correct challenging words. Accuracy extends across the essay; the adjective-form slip before the noun for a society does not involve an intended simple word.

Repeated words are counted once. The two challenging credits are direct appendix matches, not judgements based on word length.

Spelling evidence

Difficult (27)

  • further · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 102, persuasive p. 107. Difficult in the supplied appendix.
  • fragile · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 102, persuasive p. 107. Difficult in the supplied appendix.
  • equipment · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 102, persuasive p. 107. Difficult in the supplied appendix.
  • precious · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 104, persuasive p. 109. Difficult in the supplied appendix.
  • Picture · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 104, persuasive p. 109. Difficult in the supplied appendix; capitalised at sentence start.
  • sacred · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 105, persuasive p. 110. Difficult in the supplied appendix.
  • future · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 102, persuasive p. 107. Difficult in the supplied appendix.
  • choice · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 101, persuasive p. 106. Difficult in the supplied appendix.
  • acknowledge · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 101, persuasive p. 106. Difficult in the supplied appendix.
  • support · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 105, persuasive p. 110. Difficult in the supplied appendix.
  • knowledge · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 103, persuasive p. 108. Difficult in the supplied appendix.
  • civilisation · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 101, persuasive p. 106. Difficult in the supplied appendix.
  • responsible · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 105, persuasive p. 110. Difficult in the supplied appendix.
  • population · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: the unstressed medial vowel and the -ation ending are both represented in a multisyllabic word.
  • colonise · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: the second o is unstressed, and the verb has the Australian -ise ending.
  • Colonising · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: retains the unstressed medial o and drops the final e of the verb before -ing.
  • atmosphere · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: the unstressed medial vowel and the ph spelling in the second element are not predictable from sound alone.
  • radiation · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: preserves the sequence of vowel letters where the stem leads into the -ation ending.
  • meteorites · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: preserves the internal vowel sequence of meteor before the -ite ending and plural s.
  • defenceless · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: preserves the -ce spelling of the Australian base word before -less.
  • collapsing · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: retains the doubled internal l while dropping the base word's final e before -ing.
  • petrified · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: retains the unstressed internal i and changes the base-final y to i before -ed.
  • descendants · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: combines medial sc with the unstressed -ant ending and the plural consonant cluster.
  • scientists · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: represents the initial sci- sequence and retains the full -sts cluster in the plural.
  • generations · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: combines a soft initial g and an unstressed medial vowel with the -ation ending and plural s.
  • resources · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: retains the ou spelling and the soft c of the stem in the inflected form.
  • extinction · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: retains the nct letter sequence of the base before -ion despite the change in pronunciation.

Challenging (2)

  • blasé · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 101, persuasive p. 106. Challenging in the supplied appendix.
  • brilliance · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 101, persuasive p. 106. Challenging in the supplied appendix.

Year 5 interpretation

The safety paragraph shows the Year 5, NSW Stage 3 skill of building a paragraph around an idea that matters to the reader: which lives are at risk. The next step is to choose an example that also helps the reader judge the proposed solution. This is a teaching judgement about this piece, not an official NAPLAN band, a comparison with other Year 5 writers or a reading age.

Ideas · Next descriptor. The writer skilfully selects and crafts ideas into a highly persuasive case.

Audience · Next descriptor. A credible voice and sustained, precise choices manage the relationship with the reader, anticipate their expectations and influence their response.

What you did well

In your safety paragraph, you move from plants swept away by water to a joey losing its home and then to a child escaping a fire. Each scene gives the reader someone or something specific to care about.

You begin by asking the reader to think about population growth. Later, your question about what we leave future generations gives the reader a different role: now they have a decision to make.

Your next step

Revisit the end of your safety paragraph. The child escaping the fire shows why people need protection, but it does not yet show why moving to Enceladus would protect them better than helping them stay safe on Earth. That is the choice your reader needs help making.

Try this revision

Keep one scene and rewrite the ending of that paragraph around it. Use one example you can back up to compare the two choices for the life you pictured. Explain what that comparison tells you, even if it means making a smaller claim. Ask a partner to point to the detail that helped them weigh the two choices, not just picture the danger.

Classroom rubric adapted from the ACARA Writing Persuasive marking guide, © ACARA 2027. Descriptors have been rephrased. Source information · CC BY 4.0.

The figures in this piece are the writer’s claims. Before revising, ask which source supports each one.