Skip to report
The Gentle Marker

Classroom sample · Teacher report

Beyond the Ridges

Rubric total32 / 47Narrative · 10 criteria

These marks describe this piece of writing. Only the national test gives a NAPLAN proficiency level. NAPLAN writing levels explained.

Original writing

Year 5 narrative

A character’s first name has been changed in this public copy.

Beyond the Ridges

Inside the Wildlife Rescue Centre, Dr Roar looked into the eyes of her brave rescuer, Ivy Zoo. "Take this large net and catch the mysterious and endangered black panther that's said to roam the Blue Mountains before nightfall" Sweat ran down Ivy as the smell of manure filled her nostrils. As the nervous rescuer walked over to her bright yellow bike, she wondered, "Will I ever return."

As Ivy rode her bike out of the Wildlife Centre, she felt a pop in her bike. When Ivy looked down, she noticed her wheel had fallen off. The young girl knew she had to think fast to fix the bike. So she got her emergency screw driver and screwed the wheel back in place. Not perfect, but it would have to do. Safe… for now…

As 4 O'clock came, Ivy was paddling on her bike when she felt her body swealing up, bright red and itchy. Mosquitos stood in Ivys path, in the grassy plain, blocking her way. Her body felt itchier and itchier by the minute so the sore girl putt on her fluffy jump suit that covered her entire body and bravely went through. Ivy put on some tree sap to help with the swelling. After the swealing went down she continued her journey until…..

As the sun was going down, Ivy reached her destination (the Blue Mountains), she noticed a black ball of fluff on the other side of a steep cliff. The black panther fast asleep was out of Ivy's reach. The tired rescuer couldn't giver up yet so she tied some strong vines threw it to the other side of the cliff. Finally, Ivy put some food on the vines and watched the food motivated panther walk on. She took the panther and put him in a big crate. Mission complete!

As the stars filled the sky, Ivy waved goodbye to the Blue Mountains and headed on her journey, very well prepared. She called Dr Roar, who was very pleased to her Ivys voice again. She went back to the Wildlife Rescue Centre and put the black panther in her pen. She started to wonder what her next mission would be.

Rubric evidence and judgement

All ten narrative criteria are shown. Marks are provisional for teacher review. The original classroom prompt and any shared model wording were not available.

Observed form. Third-person adventure story

The original classroom prompt and any model text were unavailable. The assessment is based on the submitted narrative; no off-topic penalty or copied-material exclusion has been applied.

A confirmed simple-word misspelling limits Spelling to at most 3 out of 6.

Audience

4 / 6

"Take this large net and catch the mysterious and endangered black panther that's said to roam the Blue Mountains before nightfall" Will I ever return. Not perfect, but it would have to do. Safe… for now…

The nightfall deadline gives the reader a reason to worry about delays. Ivy’s private question makes that worry personal, and the pause after the bike repair invites the reader to anticipate more trouble. The later obstacles are resolved quickly, so the suspense is not sustained at the same level.

The ending answers Ivy’s opening fear: she returns safely and is now curious about another mission.

Text structure

3 / 4

When Ivy looked down, she noticed her wheel had fallen off. The black panther fast asleep was out of Ivy's reach. Finally, Ivy put some food on the vines and watched the food motivated panther walk on. She took the panther and put him in a big crate. Mission complete! She went back to the Wildlife Rescue Centre and put the black panther in her pen.

The briefing establishes a goal, the damaged bike and insects delay Ivy, and the cliff presents a problem she must solve to reach the panther. Luring it with food earns the resolution, though the crucial step from the panther approaching the vines to Ivy securing it in the crate is compressed.

The return to the rescue centre closes the original mission before the writer looks ahead to another.

Ideas

3 / 5

So she got her emergency screw driver and screwed the wheel back in place. Ivy put on some tree sap to help with the swelling. Finally, Ivy put some food on the vines and watched the food motivated panther walk on.

The writer develops resourcefulness through distinct decisions: Ivy repairs the wheel, treats the swelling and uses food to draw the panther within reach. These ideas serve the mission, but each solution largely closes its own episode rather than changing how Ivy handles the next one.

Persistence is evident in Ivy’s actions; its consequences beyond completing the mission receive little development.

Character and setting

3 / 4

As the nervous rescuer walked over to her bright yellow bike, she wondered, "Will I ever return." The young girl knew she had to think fast to fix the bike. Not perfect, but it would have to do. a black ball of fluff on the other side of a steep cliff.

Ivy emerges as anxious but practical: she doubts she will return, yet thinks through a repair and accepts that it only has to last. The grassy plain and steep cliff do more than name places; each creates a different difficulty. Ivy’s inner reactions are less developed once she reaches the panther.

The opening fear and closing curiosity give Ivy some movement as a character, while the intervening action chiefly shows her competence.

Vocabulary

4 / 5

the smell of manure filled her nostrils Her body felt itchier and itchier by the minute tree sap a black ball of fluff food motivated panther walk on

Precise choices recur across the adventure. Smell establishes the rescue centre, the repeated comparative conveys worsening discomfort, and the first glimpse of the panther describes what Ivy can see from a distance. Less exact wording about riding the bike and the panther’s movement limits fluency.

The effective vocabulary describes sensations and actions as well as naming things associated with wildlife rescue.

Cohesion

3 / 4

before nightfall As the sun was going down, Ivy reached her destination (the Blue Mountains) she tied some strong vines threw it to the other side of the cliff. As the stars filled the sky, Ivy waved goodbye to the Blue Mountains

The deadline, setting sun and appearance of the stars let the reader track the whole trip. Past tense is sustained, and repeated references to the rescue centre connect departure and return. There is a local loss of clarity when a singular pronoun follows the plural vines.

The journey is readily followed, although successive episodes rely heavily on the same time-clause opening.

Paragraphing

2 / 2

Not perfect, but it would have to do. Safe… for now… As 4 O'clock came, Mission complete! As the stars filled the sky,

Each of the five narrative paragraphs has a clear job: briefing, bike repair, insect encounter, capture and return. The break after the provisional repair leaves a beat of uncertainty; the break after the capture separates the climax from the quieter journey home.

The divisions mark changes in the action rather than merely separating individual sentences or speakers.

Sentence structure

4 / 6

When Ivy looked down, she noticed her wheel had fallen off. Not perfect, but it would have to do. Safe… for now… The tired rescuer couldn't giver up yet so she tied some strong vines threw it to the other side of the cliff. She started to wonder what her next mission would be.

Most constructions work, including a time clause followed by an observation, coordinated actions and an embedded question at the end. Short units vary the pace after the repair. Control falters at the cliff, where two successive actions are missing a grammatical link.

The clipped units after the repair have a discernible dramatic purpose, unlike the missing connection between tying and throwing the vines.

Punctuation

3 / 5

before nightfall" Sweat ran down Ivy Will I ever return." When Ivy looked down, she noticed her wheel had fallen off. her destination (the Blue Mountains), she noticed Mission complete! her Ivys voice again.

Most sentences have correct boundaries, and commas after introductory clauses, contraction apostrophes and an exclamation mark are used successfully. The briefing lacks an end mark, the direct question ends with a full stop, and a comma joins independent clauses on arrival at the cliffs. Possessive apostrophes are also inconsistent.

Boundary control holds across most of the narrative but not consistently in dialogue and longer sentences.

Spelling

3 / 6

the sore girl putt on her fluffy jump suit Ivy put on some tree sap to help with the swelling. mysterious and endangered emergency journey putt

Most simple and common words are correct, including well over twenty distinct common words. There is considerable difficult-word credit, but the verb for putting on the suit has an extra final consonant. Its intended form is simple on narrative p. 104, so 3 is the ceiling.

Later correct occurrences of the clothing verb’s intended spelling do not cancel the error. Missing possessive apostrophes are assessed under Punctuation.

Spelling evidence

Confirmed simple-word spelling. putt → put

Difficult (21)

  • Sweat · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 105, persuasive p. 110. Appendix: difficult, narrative p. 105.
  • nervous · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 104, persuasive p. 109. Appendix: difficult, narrative p. 104.
  • emergency · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 102, persuasive p. 107. Appendix: difficult, narrative p. 102.
  • minute · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 104, persuasive p. 109. Appendix: difficult, narrative p. 104; used here as a unit of time.
  • journey · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 103, persuasive p. 108. Appendix: difficult, narrative p. 103; counted once.
  • Finally · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 102, persuasive p. 107. Appendix: difficult, narrative p. 102.
  • complete · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 102, persuasive p. 107. Appendix: difficult, narrative p. 102.
  • voice · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 106, persuasive p. 111. Appendix: difficult, narrative p. 106.
  • wonder · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 106, persuasive p. 111. Appendix: difficult, narrative p. 106.
  • rescuer · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: the agent noun retains the cue sequence of the base before final r.
  • mysterious · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: internal y and the change from the final y of mystery to i before -ous.
  • endangered · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: prefixed and inflected form retaining the soft-g spelling of danger before the past-tense ending.
  • Mountains · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: stressed ou contrasts with ai in the unstressed second syllable; the spelling is retained in the plural place name.
  • manure · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: weak first-syllable vowel and less predictable final -ure spelling.
  • wondered · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: inflected form of the appendix difficult base wonder, retaining o for the stressed vowel before adding -ed.
  • Mosquitos · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: the borrowed word uses qu for /k/ before i. The plural in -os is an accepted variant.
  • itchier · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: retains tch and changes the adjective’s final y to i before comparative -er.
  • continued · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: the inflected multisyllabic verb preserves the less predictable final -ue sequence of the base.
  • destination · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: unstressed medial vowel and the derivational -ation ending.
  • motivated · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: unstressed medial i and the spelling change at the end of motivate before -ed.
  • Mission · Marker judgement. Pattern judgement: double s in the -ssion spelling for the final unstressed syllable; counted once across capitalisation.

Year 5 interpretation

For Year 5 in NSW Stage 3, the bike-repair paragraph shows how a paragraph can develop one idea that matters to the reader: Ivy can keep going, but her repair might not last. This is a teaching judgement about this narrative, not an official NAPLAN band, a comparison with other students or a reading age.

Character and setting · Next descriptor. Selected details create a distinctive, convincing character, or sustain a particular setting and atmosphere across the story.

What you did well

You end the bike-repair paragraph while Ivy is still unsure whether the wheel will hold. That pause lets us feel relieved that she can ride again and worried that she might not get far.

You let us see how Ivy changes. Before she sets off, she worries that she might not come home. When she gets back, she is already wondering about another mission. That contrast tells us something about her that finishing the rescue alone would not.

Your next step

At the cliff, you show us that Ivy cannot reach the sleeping panther, but then she is already tying vines. Let us see what gives her the idea. Seeing how she thinks when time is short would make her final choice more convincing.

Try this revision

Revisit just the gap between Ivy spotting the panther and tying the vines. Try two sentences: show one thing she notices, then show how it helps her choose what to do. Read the paragraph to someone and ask what gave Ivy her idea. Can they point to the clue without you explaining it?

Classroom rubric adapted from the ACARA Writing Narrative marking guide, © ACARA 2027. Descriptors have been rephrased. Source information · CC BY 4.0.