Classroom sample · Teacher report
Student E’s narrative
These marks describe this piece of writing. Only the national test gives a NAPLAN proficiency level. NAPLAN writing levels explained.
Original writing
Year 5 narrative
Inside the Magic Mountain headquarters, commander Mia Mountain looked into the eyes of her young but courageous protégé, Asher Avalanche. Mia placed a dusty map on the lab desk, " Your mission is to uncover the truth about the runaway black panther in the Blue Mountains, because to many people have been causing violence over it". The flabbergasted explorers head pounded, and sweat trickled down her spine. She didn't have time to lose, she was already suiting up her emergency kit and map. She thought about if she would ever taste her mums chicken soup ever again, and with that she started her journey.
After days of exploration, she made it a quarter way through, her legs were sore, she had dark bags under her eyes and Asher was sleep deprived. "Ow" she screamed, Asher had just cut her arm on a large rock. She scrambled to find her med kit, the cut was stinging, she was sweating, and the stressed protégé finally bandaged it up. She sat down for a long time, and just thought about how far she had left. Safe for now…
Finally, she had made it to the location where the panther was once seen. She sat on a cliff and took a deep breath, and took in how far she had come. Woosh, crumble, the map had flown away from the strong winds. The sound of silence was loud, she could taste the coffee she had that morning. As she ran to try catch it she fell on her face but got back up, she still couldn't feel her legs and was exhausted of hiking. And yes!, the relived hiker had gotten hold of the rusty map and shoved it into her bag angrily.
At the vast open plains, Asher hid behind a tree and took a good look at the majestic mythical creature. It was guarding a eucalyptus tree on the other side of the cliff, and was shivering due to the cold. With shaking hands, Asher grabbed her axe and started chopping down the bottom of the tree. It started falling towards the other side and crashed into it, then she started walking across it, her heart pounding, throat dry as a rock. Asher had finally gotten to the other side where the panther was, she took out her fluffiest blanket and placed it onto her, while taking images to prove it.
As the sunset faded, the long awaited Magic Mountain company sweated with every minute. She radioed Commander Mia Mountain, she could hear cheers from the other side with made her smile. She settled down another eucalyptus tree and thought about what her next mission would be.
Rubric evidence and judgement
All ten narrative criteria are shown. Marks are provisional for teacher review. The original classroom prompt and any shared model wording were not available.
Observed form. Third-person adventure story
The original classroom prompt and any model or starter were unavailable. The assessment concerns the handling of the narrative on the page; it makes no finding about originality or alignment with an unseen prompt.
Audience
4 / 6
She thought about if she would ever taste her mums chicken soup ever again, and with that she started her journey.
Safe for now…
And yes!, the relived hiker had gotten hold of the rusty map and shoved it into her bag angrily.
The briefing gives the reader a goal, but it is Asher’s fear of never tasting her mother’s soup again that makes the danger personal. A brief pause after her injury invites the reader to anticipate more trouble. That suspense is less sustained when the map is recovered almost immediately.
The reader has reason to care about the explorer as well as the outcome of her assignment.
Text structure
3 / 4
Your mission is to uncover the truth about the runaway black panther in the Blue Mountains, because to many people have been causing violence over it
It started falling towards the other side and crashed into it, then she started walking across it, her heart pounding, throat dry as a rock.
she took out her fluffiest blanket and placed it onto her, while taking images to prove it.
She radioed Commander Mia Mountain, she could hear cheers from the other side with made her smile.
The briefing sets up a search. Injury and a lost map delay it, and the final obstacle requires Asher to make a crossing before she can help and photograph the panther. The radio call closes the mission, although it does not explain how the discovery resolves the violence that prompted the search.
The resolution follows from Asher’s actions rather than arriving by chance; it settles the search more fully than the opening conflict.
Ideas
3 / 5
She scrambled to find her med kit, the cut was stinging, she was sweating, and the stressed protégé finally bandaged it up.
It was guarding a eucalyptus tree on the other side of the cliff, and was shivering due to the cold.
she took out her fluffiest blanket and placed it onto her, while taking images to prove it.
The hardships develop the idea of persistence through actions and consequences: Asher treats a wound, retrieves the map and finds a way across the cliff. The shivering panther gives her a reason to do more than collect proof. That promising idea of care enters late and is not developed beyond the blanket.
The episodes serve a common quest, but most obstacles cease to matter once that episode ends.
Character and setting
3 / 4
She thought about if she would ever taste her mums chicken soup ever again, and with that she started her journey.
It was guarding a eucalyptus tree on the other side of the cliff, and was shivering due to the cold.
With shaking hands, Asher grabbed her axe and started chopping down the bottom of the tree.
Asher emerges as frightened but resourceful. Her thought of home reveals what she fears losing, and her shaking hands show that she acts despite fear. The cliff matters because it separates her from the animal. Much of the remaining description repeats signs of strain rather than giving Asher a more distinctive outlook.
Action and inner thought reveal more about Asher than the opening description of her does.
Vocabulary
4 / 5
young but courageous protégé
sweat trickled down her spine
She scrambled to find her med kit
the rusty map
eucalyptus tree
her fluffiest blanket
Specific choices recur across the adventure: the mentor–novice relationship is named precisely, sweat traces a physical reaction, and the verb for seeking the kit conveys urgency. The named tree and textured blanket sharpen the encounter. Other choices are less exact, notably the description of the recovered paper map.
Precise language extends beyond the opening, though not every descriptive choice fits its object equally well.
Cohesion
3 / 4
thought about how far she had left.
and took in how far she had come.
It started falling towards the other side and crashed into it, then she started walking across it
thought about what her next mission would be.
Past-tense narration and recurring references to the map and mission keep the journey trackable. A particularly effective link changes Asher’s attention from the distance still ahead to the distance already covered. Local references are less controlled during the crossing, where successive pronouns point to different things.
The sequence is readily recoverable across paragraphs; it is the physical action within the crossing that takes some rereading.
Paragraphing
2 / 2
Safe for now…
Finally, she had made it to the location where the panther was once seen.
while taking images to prove it.
As the sunset faded, the long awaited Magic Mountain company sweated with every minute.
The five paragraphs distinguish the briefing, the injured traveller’s pause, the map incident, the encounter and the report. Ending the injury paragraph on a moment of provisional safety creates suspense across the break. The final break shifts attention from the photographic proof to the people waiting for news.
Each break marks a change in the reader’s focus, not merely the end of a sentence.
Sentence structure
3 / 6
She sat down for a long time, and just thought about how far she had left.
Finally, she had made it to the location where the panther was once seen.
As she ran to try catch it she fell on her face but got back up, she still couldn't feel her legs and was exhausted of hiking.
With shaking hands, Asher grabbed her axe and started chopping down the bottom of the tree.
Several constructions work, including an embedded question after a thought verb, a relative clause locating the sighting and a fronted phrase followed by coordinated actions. Even allowing for missing sentence stops, repeated clause chains, faulty verb complements and awkward prepositions keep complex sentences from working consistently.
The problems are not all punctuation problems: inserting a stop after the fall would still leave the verb and preposition choices in that passage to repair.
Punctuation
2 / 5
She didn't have time to lose, she was already suiting up her emergency kit and map.
her mums chicken soup
"Ow" she screamed, Asher had just cut her arm on a large rock.
Finally, she had made it to the location where the panther was once seen.
With shaking hands, Asher grabbed her axe and started chopping down the bottom of the tree.
Several sentences have correct boundaries, and introductory commas and contraction apostrophes sometimes guide the reading well. Commas repeatedly stand in for stops between independent clauses, however. Missing possessive apostrophes and inconsistent punctuation around speech add further interruptions.
Correct starts and final stops do not compensate for the frequency of unmarked sentence boundaries within those stretches.
Spelling
5 / 6
courageous protégé
to many people
emergency kit
relived hiker
eucalyptus
with made her smile
Every attempted simple word is correct in context, and most common words are correct. The inventory includes 22 distinct difficult words and three challenging words; correct difficult spellings clearly outnumber errors. Accuracy falls short of 6: the quantity expression needs too, the hiker’s reaction needs relieved, and the final relative link needs which.
The homophone error at offset 280 is on intended too, classified as common, not on intended simple to. Missing possessive apostrophes are assessed under Punctuation. Repetitions of the same spelling do not increase the inventory.
Spelling evidence
Difficult (22)
- Mountain · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 104, persuasive p. 109. Appendix: difficult.
- headquarters · Marker judgement. Feature-based: the compound retains two different non-transparent vowel spellings, ea in the first element and quar- in the second.
- commander · Marker judgement. Feature-based: doubled medial m and unstressed vowels in the first and final syllables.
- Avalanche · Marker judgement. Feature-based: the lexical word used as a surname retains the French-derived final -che for the sh sound and an unstressed medial vowel.
- mission · Marker judgement. Feature-based: the unstressed shən ending is represented by -ssion rather than -tion.
- violence · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 106, persuasive p. 111. Appendix: difficult.
- flabbergasted · Marker judgement. Feature-based: doubled b and an unstressed medial -er- are retained before the inflected ending.
- sweat · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 105, persuasive p. 110. Appendix: difficult.
- emergency · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 102, persuasive p. 107. Appendix: difficult.
- journey · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 103, persuasive p. 108. Appendix: difficult.
- exploration · Marker judgement. Feature-based: the base loses final e before -ation, with a shift of stress across the derived word.
- finally · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 102, persuasive p. 107. Appendix: difficult; counted once across capitalised and lower-case occurrences.
- bandaged · Marker judgement. Feature-based: the unstressed -age syllable retains the e marking soft g when the past-tense d is added.
- location · Marker judgement. Feature-based: the change from the verb ending -ate to the noun ending -ation includes a change in the sound represented by t.
- silence · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 105, persuasive p. 110. Appendix: difficult.
- exhausted · Marker judgement. Feature-based: the stressed syllable has the unusual xh sequence followed by the au vowel spelling.
- angrily · Marker judgement. Feature-based: forming the adverb requires changing the stem-final y to i before -ly.
- mythical · Marker judgement. Feature-based: Greek-derived medial y for a short i sound combines with the unstressed ending -ical.
- creature · Marker judgement. Feature-based: the ea vowel digraph is followed by -ture representing the unstressed final syllable.
- fluffiest · Marker judgement. Feature-based: the superlative retains doubled f and changes final y to i before -est.
- minute · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 104, persuasive p. 109. Appendix: difficult; used here as a unit of time.
- radioed · Marker judgement. Feature-based: the vowel-final base is preserved before -ed, producing the unusual written sequence -ioed.
Challenging (3)
- courageous · Spelling appendix: narrative p. 101, persuasive p. 106. Appendix: challenging.
- protégé · Marker judgement. Feature-based: French loanword retaining both acute accents and the non-English g sound.
- eucalyptus · Marker judgement. Feature-based: the Greek-derived spelling combines initial eu-, medial y for a short i sound and the -pt- consonant sequence.
Year 5 interpretation
For Year 5 in NSW Stage 3, the panther encounter offers an idea worth building a paragraph around: Asher sets out to find proof but also chooses to help. This is a teaching judgement about this narrative, not an official NAPLAN band, a comparison with other students or a reading age.
Ideas · Next descriptor. Substantial and developed ideas strengthen the central story and suggest an underlying theme.
Character and setting · Next descriptor. Selected details create a distinctive, convincing character, or sustain a particular setting and atmosphere across the story.
What you did well
You let us see what Asher is afraid of losing when she wonders whether she will taste her mum’s soup again. That small thought about home gives us a reason to care whether she makes it back.
You show Asher’s hands shaking just before she uses the axe. Because we know she is frightened, her choice to cross the gap tells us more about her courage than calling her brave would.
Your next step
Pause between Asher spotting the shivering panther and reaching for her axe. We understand that she needs proof, but we only discover that she wants to help when the blanket comes out. Let us see what changes for her so that caring for the panther becomes part of what the mission means to her.
Try this revision
Before Asher reaches for the axe, add one or two sentences showing what goes through her mind as she watches the panther. Then cover the rest of the paragraph. Ask a partner what Asher wants to do now and why. Can they tell without seeing the blanket?
Classroom rubric adapted from the ACARA Writing Narrative marking guide, © ACARA 2027. Descriptors have been rephrased. Source information · CC BY 4.0.